blueyedbabe said "Lol at some of you judgmental people criticizing peoples priorities as if the world isn’t expensive as hell lately.
An extra $60-130+ a month is a financial hardship for a lot of people.
The cost of groceries, hydro, mpi, gas, rent/ mortgage is constantly increasing.
The Y is expensive! And unlike anytime fitness, you are restricted to shorter hours when you can use the gym, it’s crowded and it’s so loud. "
I am not judging anyone. We let our membership lapse in part due to cost for the exact reasons you state.
But its also important to keep perspective. It literally costs the same as Anytime Fitness, so the level of cost isn't actually the issue. It's costing $60/month no matter where you go, so it comes down to things like you mention - availability of hours etc. If swimming and aquasize are an attractant, then the Y might be a better choice.
It reminds me of the shoe paradox and the cost of being poor. I'm sure everyone has heard it by now, but in case you haven't- two people need new shoes. Person A spends $100 on a good quality pair of shoes, and proceeds to wear them 5 years (which he can, because they are good shoes). Person B can only afford $25, so they buy those, but they wear out in a year. After 5 years, they have spent $125 on shoes. In the long run, it would have been cheaper to buy the $100 shoes. That applies to so many things - it's usually cheaper to buy the more expensive thing up front in the long run. But if you literally can't afford to do it, it costs you more at the end of the day.
Now apply that to the OP. They need to go to the gym for health reasons. If they can manage the costs up rent, it will benefit them long term, maybe in better health, better rehab, and ultimately better being able to be employed and not losing time to injury or illness. It makes sense to spend the money, if you can skim enough from other areas of your life to pay for it. But if they literally can't pay for it (and many people genuinely can't), it will cost them in the long run.
The Y has subsidies available. You should inquire about the qualifications. Many gyms have a free tour/first visit. Maybe visit a fee and see if they are what you want to do. It might also be cheaper to pay a la carte if it's not going to be a regular thing.