Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 2625
I used their "Mystery Hotel" for a hotel in Montreal last year and it was the same hotel I got from a Hotwire deal the year before, which was fine with me because it was in the exact neighbourhood I wanted to be in, close to the main metro hub and near lots of great restaurants and events. If you aren't picky when it comes to hotels, I suggest it, the rooms are always clean, friendly staff and so much better than paying up to 3x more per night, which adds up if you're there for several days.
When i booked my most recent trip, Expedia's Mystery Hotel deals no longer show up, so I ended up with using Hotwire.